Re: Jesus Is a Muslim

[ Follow Ups ] [ Post Followup ] [ The Debate ] [ FAQ ]

Posted by Mistry on March 31, 1998 at 11:15:08:

In Reply to: Re: Jesus Is a Muslim posted by Mohamed Ghounem on November 12, 1997 at 10:35:00:

: { I was born into a Christian family, but that does not make me a Christian. }

: Well well well, in your 3rd Post, last sentence, you claimed "my family is Muslim" again you have been revealed to be a liar, how embarrassing "again", I do not know why I continue to discuss this any further, I think I enjoy revealing you for who you really are, "fake".

Ok good debate guys, but lets not twist words, I haven't been reading the text that closly but I've picked up on the fact that Zaphod said that PART of his faimly is Muslim. He didn't say that his WHOLE family was Muslim, true you can infer that his whole family with the exception of himself MAY BE Muslim, but by that I'd say that he is refering to wife and children and not parents. The simple backup of that is that he did say in his first response that he converted from Christianity to Islam. So if you were trying to be logical (ie not assuming every word is a lie) then you'd infer that he got married during the period of his life that he was a Muslim. So given that, that doesn't make him a liar, just makes you look bad for twisting his words, but otherwise I'm enjoying the whole thing.
Just in case either party in wondering, I'm neither Christian, or Muslim, just interested in what is being said.

Oh one more thing (directed specifically at Mohamed), the link in the following doesn't work;

http://members.aol.com/Stbarnbas/pol.htm

Follow Ups:

Re: Jesus Is a Muslim Mohamed Ghounem 3/31/98 (0)

Post a Followup

Name :
E-Mail :

Subject : Re: Re: Jesus Is a Muslim

Comments:
:
: : { I was born into a Christian family, but that does not make me a Christian. }

: : Well well well, in your <A HREF="http://debate.org.uk/weboard/debate/messages/171.html">3rd Post</A>, last sentence, you claimed "my family is Muslim" again you have been revealed to be a liar, how embarrassing "again", I do not know why I continue to discuss this any further, I think I enjoy revealing you for who you really are, "fake".

: Ok good debate guys, but lets not twist words, I haven't been reading the text that closly but I've picked up on the fact that Zaphod said that PART of his faimly is Muslim. He didn't say that his WHOLE family was Muslim, true you can infer that his whole family with the exception of himself MAY BE Muslim, but by that I'd say that he is refering to wife and children and not parents. The simple backup of that is that he did say in his first response that he converted from Christianity to Islam. So if you were trying to be logical (ie not assuming every word is a lie) then you'd infer that he got married during the period of his life that he was a Muslim. So given that, that doesn't make him a liar, just makes you look bad for twisting his words, but otherwise I'm enjoying the whole thing.
: Just in case either party in wondering, I'm neither Christian, or Muslim, just interested in what is being said.

: Oh one more thing (directed specifically at Mohamed), the link in the following doesn't work;

: http://members.aol.com/Stbarnbas/pol.htm

[ Follow Ups ] [ Post Followup ] [ The Debate ] [ FAQ ]